Chris Van Hollen Is Beatable. Just Not in the Race He’s Running.
THE MARYLAND WIRE · PAID · DRAFT — November 16, 2026
On December 1, Senate Democrats will pick their leader by secret ballot, and Chris Van Hollen will lose to Chuck Schumer. I do not say that because I have counted votes. Nobody counts votes in a secret ballot, which is the first thing to understand about this race, and the reason Chris is running in it. He says he has “15 and growing.” Schumer says, “I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader.” Both men can say anything they like, because no tally will ever be published and no one will ever know whether Chris lost by thirty or by three. It is the safest race in American politics to lose. The race that should worry him is two years away, and it is at home.
--- PAYWALL ---
Nobody votes against the man holding the committee assignments
Start with what Schumer has that Chris does not. Schumer has run the Senate Democrats since 2017. For a decade he has been the man who doled out the campaign money, raised it by the hundreds of millions through the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and his own network, made the calls that got senators their seats and kept them in them, and decided who sits where. The senators walking into that room on December 1 owe him their positions, their favors and in some cases their elections. And here is the part that ends the argument: the winner of that vote turns around in January and hands out the committee assignments for the new Congress.
A committee assignment is a young senator’s whole future. The right one puts you on the fast track — to governor, to a presidential mention, to a career. A bad one, a low-power one, marks you like a loaf of bread with a short sell-by date. Every incoming senator in that room knows the assignments get passed out after the leadership vote, by the man they are voting on. Getting the likely winner mad at you before he passes them out is a very bad way to start a Washington career. Schumer needs only a majority of his own caucus, a caucus stocked with people he has taken care of for years. The public commitments already run heavily his way, and the betting markets make him roughly a six-to-one favorite. Could the secret ballot surprise us? Secret ballots can do anything. But senators do not vote their applause lines. They vote their interests, and their interests are sitting in the front of the room holding the assignment list.
So why is Chris running? Read it as a man buying something
Because losing this race costs him nothing and buys him plenty. When the count is never announced, the loser gets to claim he came close, and no one can prove otherwise. Chris spent this past weekend on Fox News Sunday, State of the Union and This Week calling it “a wide open race.” That is not a man counting to twenty-eight. That is a man building a claim — the standing candidate of the change wing, measured and ready if Schumer stumbles, if Schumer decides at seventy-seven that 2028 is one race too many, or if Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez comes for Schumer in a New York primary and the party suddenly needs a leader who is not from New York’s old guard.
What does Chris offer the room in the meantime? The enthusiasm of the progressive wing. There is real energy in it, and there are not enough dedicated progressives in the United States Senate to elect a leader. The progressives believe Schumer can be kicked out because everyone they know wants Chris Van Hollen. The trouble is they do not know many regular Democrats. They talk to their own kind and hear their own noise reflected back. Regular Democrats are the people who actually vote in these fights, in caucus rooms and in primaries, and regular Democrats keep doing the same thing. Which brings us home.
Maryland is not a progressive state, and its primaries keep proving it
Chris Van Hollen is up for reelection in 2028, the same year as Schumer. He has been moving toward the progressive edge of his party for two years. Maryland lets you do that in pockets — Montgomery County has them, Howard County to a lesser degree — and a delegate or a state senator can march in circles waving a fist and yelling free, free, free and survive in the right district. A statewide Democratic primary is a different electorate, and it has a habit.
Mike Miller said it out loud years ago, after Ben Jealous lost a governor’s race Maryland progressives were sure was theirs. “His message might have played better in California than it did in Maryland,” Miller told reporters. “Maryland is a state of middle temperament.”
When Wes Moore won the Democratic primary for governor in 2022, he was the most centrist serious candidate in the field, and the candidates running to his left lost. This year, when Steny Hoyer retired in the 5th District, more than twenty Democrats ran for the seat and most of the field lined up on the progressive side, certain the Bernie Sanders and AOC walk was the way in. The winner was Adrian Boafo, Hoyer’s former campaign manager, the centrist, establishment-endorsed candidate, and he took twice the votes of his nearest rival. It was not close.
The exceptions prove the rule, because look what the exceptions cost. Chuck Cook won a House seat in Anne Arundel County this year as a man well to the left of his district — in a blue-wave year, behind a strong governor who put money and pressure behind the whole ticket. Ask around Annapolis whether he wins that seat in a regular year and you will get a shrug. Shaneka Henson was appointed to a Senate seat in southern Anne Arundel County that Democrats should hold in their sleep, and the only way she kept it was for Bill Ferguson’s Senate operation to pour more than a million dollars into her race — and she nearly lost anyway, to a moderately conservative Republican. Progressive candidates in Maryland survive on wave years and other people’s money. A 2028 Senate primary against a credible centrist offers Chris neither.
Two names, and neither man has said a word
Let me be plain about what this is. Nobody is announcing anything, and I am not reporting that either of these men is running. I am saying the path exists, and people in Maryland politics are already walking it with their eyes.
The first name is Bobby Zirkin. As chairman of the Judicial Proceedings Committee, Zirkin was one of the most competent senators Annapolis has had in a generation — solidly, unapologetically centrist, with a Baltimore County base. People are talking to him about 2028. He says he does not want to do it. He says his wife would kill him. Both things may be true, and the talk does not stop, because everyone who watched him run that committee believes he wants it and simply cannot sell it at home. If he ever did sell it, he would be a problem.
The second name is Ivan Bates, the State’s Attorney for Baltimore City. Somebody walked me through the map the other night and it is not complicated. Bates wins Baltimore City, his home. He wins Baltimore County, where he is genuinely popular. And he wins Prince George’s County, which is not nearly as progressive as its press clippings and which has a long memory for the times Chris Van Hollen has lined up against Black candidates there. That is three of the four biggest vote boxes in Maryland before you count a single ballot in Montgomery County. Bates has not said a word about running. He does not have to. The map says it for him.
The corner he painted himself into
And Montgomery County, his fortress, is not what it was. For twenty years Chris built his career alongside Maryland’s Jewish community and its contributors, in Montgomery County and Baltimore County both — they were his people, his first calls, his money and his organization. Then, on Gaza, he broke with them and moved to the left edge of his party on Israel, against the friends who had been with him since the beginning. Judge the merits however you like. Count the politics. He traded the most reliable base a Maryland Democrat can have for the applause of a wing that does not win Maryland primaries, and he burned bridges in Baltimore County doing it.
Now stack the whole picture. A senator who has spent two years running for a job in Washington. A base traded away. A party whose Maryland voters keep picking the centrist. And a boatload of money sitting ready for any credible challenger who wants to pick it up, because there is no shortage of people in this state who would enjoy funding the man who retires Chris Van Hollen.
On December 1 the caucus will vote, no count will be published, and Chris will say he ran strong. Maybe he did. Nobody will ever know, and that is the beauty of the race he chose. The primary of 2028 will be counted out loud, in public, county by county — Baltimore City, Baltimore County, Prince George’s, and a Montgomery County that is not his anymore. That is the race Chris Van Hollen can lose. The only question is whether anybody with the standing to beat him decides to run it.


